Posted on Thursday, November 15, 2012 - 04:56 am:
There is no 100% sure way to prove someone is playing on a certain record, especially one that took place over 50 years ago. However, a copy of an AFM session contract is about as good as it gets. Sadly enough, in those days, they didn't list the recording artist on the contract, not by default anyway. Still, there are some ways to find out for which recording artist the session was (probably) done.
In this case, I have a copy of an AFM contract for a session that took place on June 11, 1963. The session was led by arranger Ernie Freeman, and the employer was Liberty Records. More importantly, it lists the song titles they recorded:
Keep Moving Old Man
Detroit City
Sound of Silence
Moon Wanderer
These facts combined all point towards Walter Brennan's 1963 "Straight from the Heart" album (LRP-3317/LST-7317 on Liberty records) which was indeed, according to the backsleeve, arranged by Ernie Freeman.
On the contract Glen Campbell is mentioned as contributing musician, next to a host of other musicians (including a string section and a few "Wrecking Crew" musicians like Earl Palmer, and William "Bill" Pitman).
Does this prove without a doubt that Glen was on that record? No. This session could have turned out rubbish so they decided to do another one (without Glen) and use that session for the record (which taking into the number and quality of people involved in his session does not seem likely). There is also a (very small) chance this session was actually done for a completely other record. Note that the opposite can also be true. If you have a session contract that does not mention a certain musician, there is always the chance that he did contribute on some overdubbing session for which you don't have the contract!
I cannot post the contract on this forum as the Los Angeles AFM local 47 only allows personal use. The forum would not allow it either and rightly so.
So, there is also the chance that I'm making this all up! And even if I posted it, I could have forged a fake one, like president Obama did with his birth certificate!
-Cowpoke